Battle of the Cleansing Balms: Which One Removes Everything?
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
I’m a cleansing balm convert. Once you’ve watched a full face of makeup melt off without scrubbing, tugging, or praying to the skincare gods, it’s hard to go back. But not all balms are created equal.
Some just sit there. Some sting. Some leave a weird film that makes you question your life choices.
So I tested a handful of popular picks to see which ones actually remove everything—mascara, sunscreen, and the day’s regrets.
Here’s how they stacked up.
1. Banila Co Clean It Zero (Original)
Texture: Sorbet that melts instantly
Scent: Light floral
Price: ~$19
This one has cult status for a reason. It works fast, rinses clean, and leaves no greasy residue. Gets everything off—even waterproof mascara—without needing a second cleanse immediately. Doesn’t sting my eyes, either.
Solid all-rounder. Dependable. If this balm were a person, it’d text you back.
2. Heimish All Clean Balm
Texture: Soft balm that turns milky
Scent: Herbal, spa-like
Price: ~$17
This feels more luxurious than the price suggests. Very gentle on sensitive skin, and the scent is grounding. Removes everything, but you might want a second cleanse for full waterproof makeup.
The chill, botanical cousin to Banila Co. I keep this one for nighttime wind-downs.
3. Then I Met You Living Cleansing Balm
Texture: Buttery and rich
Scent: Light citrus
Price: ~$38
Yes, it’s pricey. But this balm feels like a hug for your face. Melts even the most stubborn makeup and leaves skin baby-soft. Bonus points for antioxidants and a luxe experience.
If budget isn’t your barrier, this is the gold standard. Ritual-worthy.
4. e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm
Texture: Creamy, slightly waxy
Scent: Barely noticeable
Price: ~$11
This surprised me. It works well—removes sunscreen and light makeup effortlessly. It doesn’t rinse quite as clean as the others, but it’s incredibly gentle and very wallet-friendly.
Great starter balm or travel companion. Not perfect, but perfectly fine.
5. Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm
Texture: Smooth sorbet
Scent: Bright and citrusy
Price: ~$36
This one’s been around a while and still holds up. It removes makeup fast, smells refreshing, and rinses clean. A little goes a long way, which softens the price point.
A dependable mid-splurge. Bright, quick, no fuss.
If you’re just dipping into balm cleansers, go Banila or Heimish. Want the most luxe experience? Then I Met You is hard to top. And if you’re on a budget, e.l.f. punches above its price tag.
The bottom line? Cleansing can (and should) feel like self-care.
Especially when it melts off mascara and mental clutter in one go.
Comments
Post a Comment